Investment ideas capturing the Zeitgeist
Don’t be taken by surprise by trends that were foreseeable. Instead, bring the “big picture” into sharper focus by integrating Megatrends into your portfolio.
Solar energy instead of sunflowers – or both together?
Agriculture is becoming increasingly unprofitable in large parts of the world. Now there are signs of a reversal of this trend: More and more farmers are no longer planting their fields with wheat or sunflowers, but they’re investing in photovoltaic systems. And they can live very well from this.
Where the money is in farming these days: Farmers consider to “plant” solar instead of sunflowers. © GettyImages
London-based writer specialising in technology, business and innovation.
We feature her report here as part of our Publishing Partnership with Wired UK.
For years, Mandy Wilson and her husband ran a farm just south of Carlisle in Cumbria, UK. While her husband worked the wheat and barley fields, Mandy ran the on site equestrian centre. It wasn’t a perfect living, but it worked, until her husband died. “I had to hire contractors and it just wasn’t paying,” she says, “so I was going to sell up.”
Instead, she covered 30 acres of her land in solar panels. “It’s a lifesaver,” says Wilson, who doesn’t run the solar farm herself. She rents the land to an energy company, which turns out to be a much more reliable business venture than growing grain. “Farming has gone ludicrous,” she says. “It’s actually beyond a joke. It’s got to the point now where growing wheat and barley isn’t profitable.” That’s why she, and many farmers, are farming solar energy too.
“It offers secure income for farmers and landowners, which is scarcer than hen’s teeth at the moment,” says Chris Thyer, rural associate director at GSC Grays surveyors, who helped Wilson get her solar fields up and running. “There are all sorts of questions about where the money is in farming these days,” he says, citing unpredictable weather and for those in the UK, the loss of EU support payments post Brexit. “Everyone is worried about what’s going to happen this year.”
Renting out fields is the go-to option. “From the farmer’s perspective, their core business is still going to be farming,” Thyer says. “All of this is someone else’s project that’s happening on their land.” The farmers can focus their energy on tending to their other fields of sheep and vegetables, while the solar panels provide a consistent flow of money and security.
When Wilson got into solar, government subsidies were still in place, so small 30-acre plots were still a worthwhile investment. Now, the subsidies are gone, so the projects need to be bigger to make real money, because installing the panels costs a massive amount. Thyer secured planning permission for a 200-acre solar project in Yorkshire late last year, for example, which will power 15,000 homes. A project of that scale “could cost tens of millions to build,” he says.
This need for massive acreage makes farming land even more desirable, because it’s hard to find the space elsewhere. In cities, you’d be lucky to get a couple of rooftops. And on the outskirts of urban areas, you’d be competing with housing developments. “So it only really works in more remote locations,” says Thyer.
There are rules though. You can’t cover up the most fertile land. Planning permission will only be granted to lower-yield fields or grass used for grazing. When the solar panels are installed, the fields can still be used, either by filling them with bumblebee-friendly flowers or using them to graze small animals like sheep or goats. So, Thyer says, “any loss to food production would be minimal.”
It isn’t just happening in the UK. Research has found that farmland is likely to be one of the best places for solar farms to be created. If less than one per cent of the world’s agricultural land was converted to solar panels, it would be able to produce enough electricity for the entire world’s demand, academics at Oregon State University have found.
Discover other effective ways to manage resources more efficiently: One solution is called “smart farming”, and it claims that harvests can be increased by two-thirds. This megatrend offers investors interesting possibilities.
Converting farmland to solar doesn’t mean that the land can’t be used for agriculture. In Europe, they’re testing a hybrid system that puts solar panels and full-force vegetable farming in the same fields. Fraunhofer, a German research organisation, has been working with a farm near Konstanz in South Germany for more than three years on a project that uses the same familiar solar panels, just propped 12 metres in the air. The setup is high enough that tractors and harvesters can still work below it, so crops can be grown underneath. They’ve given it the catchy name: agrophotovoltaics (APV).
“It doesn’t completely cover the canopy, so there is still some light coming through,” says Iris Lewandowski, chief bioeconomy officer at the University of Hohenheim, who works on the project. “The only difference for the farmers is that they have to make sure they don’t drive into the pillars.”
The dual-harvest system is still in the testing phases, but it has already proven that land can be used for both growing crops and generating power. The land restrictions are different in Europe – you can’t convert farmland into something else, not matter how infertile – so this is a way to get solar panels onto farmland without repurposing it entirely. There are also other options available: in the Netherlands work is underway on creating Europes largest floating solar farm. As available land in the country is sparse the solar farm is being built on a sandpit lake. The technology could make previously unusable spaces a boom for solar farms.
But the dual-harvest system also seems to work. The team at Fraunhofer have been monitoring the crop yields from below the APV system for several years. Most years, production levels dropped about ten per cent because of the shade, but in hotter years, such as 2018, some of the crops actually benefitted from being blocked from the sun. Potatoes and wheat both saw a three per cent increase, but the biggest winner was the celery plants, which saw a 12 per cent gain.
“The yield wasn’t effected,” says Lewandowski, meaning there were the same number of plants as expected, “but it grew more leaves.” While the number of celeriac (celery root) produced was about the same as usual, the protection from the solar panels boosted the amount of celery (celery leaves) harvested. “The microclimate underneath the solar panels changed and that impacted the development,” she says. That’s good news, especially for arid regions.
Fraunhofer did a pilot project on a farm in Maharashtra, India, where they were growing cotton and tomatoes. The shade from the panels not only protected the tomatoes and cotton from the heat, it also prevented water from evaporating, and led to a 40 per cent higher yield of both crops. The Oregon State University academics have also looked at the viability of using solar panels as part of a dual-harvest and have also observed success. “Researchers have successfully grown aloe vera, tomatoes, biogas maize, pasture grass, and lettuce in agrivoltaic experiments,” they write.
“In Europe, regions that would really benefit would be in the south, like Spain,” says Lewandowski, or any other arid location. More temperate regions are more likely to see crop yield losses of about ten per cent. That’s not the end of the world, as the power generated by the panels would be enough to counteract the loss economically. But the initial investment in the giant 12-metre-high steel structure is massive, so that may put investors off. “I don’t know the break even point,” says Lewandowski, “but if I was to advise someone to go for it, it would be in an arid region”.
Who are we? How do we live today? And how will solar energy change farming? The issue of a sustainable future is preoccupying society more than ever, with engineers, doctors, politicians – each one of us, in fact – seeking answers. This report by Wired UK is one of many contributions that shed light on sustainability from a new, inspiring perspective. We are publishing them here as part of our series “Impact on Investors”.